However, unlike Desdemona, Cassio evolves as a character. But her denials only make Othello more angry—he calls her a whore, and, after giving Emilia money for guarding the door, storms out. Iago hates Othello because Othello gave Cassio the military promotion he wanted. Suddenly a sail is descried. Emilia enters and tells Cassio that Desdemona has been speaking in his favor but that Othello heard that the man he hurt was a great man of Cyprus and that that makes his position difficult but that he does love him and can’t find anyone else to suit the position. and entrusts him with punishing Iago. Cassio is charged with determining Iago’s punishment, and urges “the time, the place, the torture, oh, enforce it” (5.2.). Iago acts like he cares and tells Cassio to let things settle and he will end … In addition to his innate appeal, Cassio’s behavior to women unwittingly endangers both himself and Desdemona. Trust and anger at the same people. Cassio is the kind of guy who likes to put women in one of two categories – virgin or whore. What does Othello claim that he wants in the end of act 3 scene 2? He is aiming at exactly what happens--that Desdemona will plead on Cassio's behalf, and make Othello wonder "Why is she so interested in Cassio anyway?" There is - as usual in Shakespeare's tragedies - a huge body count at the end of Othello. What happens to Othello, Iago, and Cassio in the end? Cassio declares he's forever indebted to her, and Desdemona again emphasizes that she'll do everything she can. Othello tells Cassio to keep the party under control. Her revelation is corroborated by information from Cassio and a letter found in Roderigo’s pocket. Immediately before he stabs himself, Othello draws a comparison to how he killed “a malignant and turbaned Turk…the circumcised dog” (5.2.). I have lost the immortal part of myself, and what remains is bestial" (2.3.251-3). From a distance, Othello hears Cassio's shouts of pain and believes that Iago has killed Cassio. Asked By Wiki User. He says to Othello that it can’t have been Cassio because ‘I cannot think it that he would steal away so guilty-like seeing you coming’. Under Othello's pressure, the typically honest Desdemona is herself forced to equivocate. Iago persuades Roderigo that the only way to stop Desdemona from slipping forever beyond his reach is to kill Cassio, which will keep Othello in Cyprus. They hope to awaken Brabantio and convince him to turn against Othello. Othello tells her that he found her handkerchief with Cassio, though Desdemona insists it must not be true; she pleads with Othello not to kill her, but he begins to smother her. But he adds a lie: that Othello, rather than returning to Venice, is being sent to Mauritania along with Desdemona. Share a link to this question via Google+, Twitter, or Facebook. What does he really lead Cassio to talk about? For this slave, If there be any cunning cruelty That can torment him much and hold him long, It shall be his. At the end of Othello, Iago has thoroughly convinced Othello that Desdemona is having an affair with Cassio, even though this is a complete fiction.Othello smothers Desdemona, killing her. Otello killed himself after … I will gyve thee in thine own courtship” (2.1.). Desdemona entreats Othello to forgive Cassio and reinstate him as lieutenant. From a distance, Othello hears Cassio's shouts of pain and believes that Iago has killed Cassio. But so is Desdemona—for at least three more seconds. The ending symbolizes the culmination of the violent forces put in motion by Iago at the start of the play. Left alone with Roderigo, Iago reveals phase one of operation Undermine Othello’s Happiness. Answered by Anonymous on 17th December, 2009. Emilia brings the news of Roderigo's death, and Cassio's wounding. Report This. When Desdemona cannot produce the handkerchief he wants to see, Othello explains the handkerchiefs histor… Desdemona is killed by othello because he is enraged of jealousy.As result of Iago intentions to ruin othello by making him believe that Desdemona was being cheating on him with his friend Cassio. who is't that cried?" Iago, however, counsels him to approach Desdemona for help. Emilia, who is less idealistic and more worldly than Desdemona, immediately understands that Othello's behavior stems from jealousy. Desdemona exits, saying "I am obedient" (3.3.90). The play ends in a spectacle of tragic violence: Emilia intercepts Othello after he’s murdered Desdemona and reveals Iago’s treachery. Iago makes sure Othello sees the end of their conversation and notices Cassio leaving Desdemona. It gets rid of Cassio because Othello won't like that Desdemona is having an affair ... What happens in Act 3 to the handkerchief Desdemona tries to use to soothe Othello? ... What happens to Cassio in the end? Roderigo comes in, fresh from the beating from Cassio, and says he thinks he should give up and go back to Venice, as now he's poor and bruised up. It also comes back to bite Cassio in the end, since his flirtatious charisma helps convince Othello that Cassio is having sex with Desdemona. Why? In his final speech, he explains how he hopes to be remembered, saying “When you shall these unlucky deed relate / Speak of me as I am” (5.2.). After Othello says he trusts Iago (bad move), he tells Desdemona he's paid for her by marrying her, and now it's about time that he gets to collect. He then asks her to lend him her handkerchief. Iago tells Roderigo ‘I follow him to serve my turn upon him’. Othello comes out of his trance, and Iago explains that Cassio stopped by and that he has arranged to speak with the ex-lieutenant. Asked by Anonymous on 13th December, 2009 about Othello Study Guide. Report This +1-4-1. Watching Cassio touch Desdemona’s hand, Iago schemes that “Ay, smile upon her, do! She even says, "Thy solicitor shall rather die/ Than give thy cause away" (3.3.27-28). Finally inside, Emilia reports (wrongly) that Roderigo has been killed by Cassio, and that Cassio is wounded, but not dead. Iago asks if Cassio knew who he was chasing after, but Cassio says that he can't remember anything distinctly. ... What happens to Othello at the end of this play? Analysis. Iago explains that he will make Cassio retell the story of where, when, how, and how often he has slept with Desdemona, and when he intends to do so again. He then tells Roderigo about Cassio being promoted by the Duke to take Othello 's place as defender of Cyprus. The quote means Iago only serves Othello so he can get what he wants. He predicts that talking of Bianca will make Cassio laugh, and that Othello, thinking they are talking about Desdemona, will go mad. Cassio counterattacks, wounding Roderigo. Othello than says he could have handled any affliction but infidelity. Roderigo is to cause Cassio to lose his lieutenancy by provoking him into a brawl. Othello’s suicide serves as a kind of trial in which he decides on and enacts a punishment for his crime of killing Desdemona. A terrible storm has struck Cyprus, just as the Turks were about to approach. Explain Othello's change of heart. His name is cleared by Emilia and as Othello is stripped of his duties, we are told that Cassio now rules in Cyprus. Iago, however, counsels him to approach Desdemona for help. At the end of Act III, scene iii,what does Othello say he will do about Cassio?about Desdemona? Othello sends Emilia outside to guard the door. Cassio was wounded from behind by Iago. After desdemona murder Othello confesses that he killed her with much pride. As the clown departs, Desdemona wonders to Emilia where her handkerchief might be. Cassio is charged with determining Iago’s punishment, and urges “the time, the place, the torture, oh, enforce it” (5.2.). Cassio agrees, and Iago uses his wife, Emilia, to arrange a private meeting between Cassio and Desdemona. 40-2) This powerful visual image of Cassio using a handkerchief, which Othello so cherishes and which represents his love for Desdemona, in such a base and unrefined way is likely to cloud Othello’s good judgement and have his impulses lead him to accept what Iago says as the truth. Cassio despairs at his lost reputation: "O, I have lost my reputation! *Othello fires Cassio (rash decision, he never even thought about it, this shows Othello acts on his emotions) *Iago happy that Cassio is fired, but Iago didn't get placed 2nd in Command *Cassio is MOST upset about his reputation. In a vain attempt to prevent his scheme from being revealed, Iago stabs and kills Emilia, and is then taken prisoner while Othello, lamenting the loss of his wife, kills himself next to her. To keep an eye out on the guards so that the party doesn’t get too wild at the end: What, in general, are Iago and Cassio saying about Desdemona at the beginning of act 2 scene 3: Iago is taunting Cassio trying to get him to admit that he has feelings for Desdemona: Why does Cassio not want to drink? Their happiness is a fitting end to the Turkish wars. Othello kills himself. What are Othello’s orders to Cassio? Although Othello killed his wife Desdemona, Iago's wife Emilia was able to reveal much of her husband's evil plot before Iago was able to stab her. Iago told Othello that he would question Cassio about his affair with Desdemona. All the noise wakes Othello, who comes down to figure out what has happened. The play ends with a depressed Ludovico saying that he hopes that Cassio will punish Iago, and that he'll relate the whole story of the seedy Othello affair to the state. Othello and Desdemona leave to consummate their marriage. Active Themes Othello enters, frantic and furious, and says to Iago that he would have been happier to be deceived than to suspect. What did Iago do after he wounded Cassio? Know someone who can answer? What happens to Othello, Iago and Cassio in the end? It is Othello! Iago has been so successful that Othello feels compelled to kill himself, explaining that “I kissed thee ere I killed thee—no way but this, Killing myself to die upon a kiss” (5.2.). Iago tells Othello that he will get Cassio to talk about his affair with Desdemona while Othello watches. (5.1.74). Othello asks whether it was Cassio he saw leaving the room, and Iago responds that surely Cassio would not behave like a guilty man at Othello’s approach. Cassio declares he's forever indebted to her, and Desdemona again emphasizes that she'll do everything she can. What happens to Othello, Iago and Cassio in the end? To keep an eye out on the guards so that the party doesn’t get too wild at the end : What, in general, are Iago and Cassio saying about Desdemona at the beginning of act 2 scene 3: Iago is taunting Cassio trying to get him to admit that he has feelings for Desdemona: Why does Cassio not want to drink? By the end of the play, he has realized that Iago is responsible for Desdemona’s death, and he helps Othello understand Iago’s treachery. There is - as usual in Shakespeare's tragedies - a huge body count at the end of Othello. After Bianca appears, what new part of his plot does Iago begin in Scene 1? This is bad timing, as Iago plants the seed that Cassio … Othello comes out, furious at the disorder, and fires Cassio. Othello thought that Cassio was irresponsible and dishonourable. Desdemona and Othello’s relationship is strained by the end of Act 3. A messenger enters, and confirms that the Turkish fleet was broken apart by the storm, and that Cassio has arrived, though Othello is still at sea. The sudden shift from the wrongly jealousy Othello at the end of the last scene to Desdemona emphasizes just how innocent and virtuous she actually is. Second, keep in mind the urgency behind the speech you're writing: Cassio has a responsibility to justice (and to keep people from spreading rumors which might lead to sedition) as well as to the moral ethos of the situation. Roderigo was wounded by Cassio. des’s uncle to make up for des’s death, and because she’s dead, her mother and father is dead, so it goes to her uncle: O balmy breath, that dost almost persuadeJustice to break her sword. Because his pockets have letters explaining the plan on it. From behind, Iago darts in and stabs Cassio in the leg, then runs away. Cassio has explained the whole situation to Desdemona, and she promises to not rest until she's convinced Othello to reinstate Cassio as his lieutenant and renew their friendship. The ending symbolizes the culmination of the violent forces put in motion by Iago at the start of the play. We also know that after Othello learns the truth (that he killed the ever-faithful Desdemona for no good reason), he decides to end his own life. Roderigo will get the blame for the attack on Cassio if Iago has his way. Iago suggests that Cassio turn to Desdemona to convince Othello to re-hire him. Othello by William Shakespeare Choose the correct answer: he is killed by Othello he kills himself he escapes he is taken into custody skip question » Ask a friend It just so happens that this "good advice" plays right into Iago's plan to make Othello jealous of Cassio. 0-1. Act 1 Scene 1 The play opens as Iago is telling Roderigo that he hates Othello because Othello has promoted Cassio to be his lieutenant instead of him, even though Cassio ‘never set a squadron in the field’ and has much less experience. Othello enters and tells Desdemona to give him her hand. The impact of the shocking betrayals and violence shown by other characters has presumably changed Cassio into a man who will be much more cautious, but possibly a better leader as a result. ... makes demands of, and gets angry with Iago. Moved by Iago's loyalty to him, Othello steels himself to go and kill Desdemona in her bed. Make everyone think it's an accident and to be able to see what is happening with othello. The planting of the handkerchief, which Othello dropped, in Cassio's room shows how jealousy produces the effect it fears. they all die: Who gets Othello’s estate? Othello is already jealous of Cassio because he is young and white, and when Othello finds Cassio with the magical handkerchief that he gave to Desdemona, he plans to kill them both. she says weakly (5.2.118.1). When he talks about Desdemona, we can tell that he sees her as a kind of secular Virgin Mary. One is that Cassio has been picked ahead of him as Lieutenant; the other is that he thinks that Othello slept with Iago's wife, Emilia.Cassio seems to have taken Iago's place in Othello's affections. Cassio notes that actually that's Iago's job, but sure, he's willing to help out. Othello leaves Cassio on guard during the revels, reminding him to practice self-restraint during the celebration. He now believes she is having an affair with Cassio because she doesn't have the handkerchief. Cassio functions mainly to move the plot forward by inadvertently becoming a pawn in Iago’s plan. Use up and down arrows to review and enter to select. Cassio ends the play in a position of significant authority and responsibility: Ludovico commands that “Cassio rules in Cyprus” (5.2.) At the end of the play, Cassio is injured but redeemed. Cassio, commanding the night watch during the time of feasting and drinking, takes his orders from Othello, who directs the soldiers to drink with moderation and keep the peace. Perhaps because Cassio is a Florentine, and not a Venetian, or because he seems to lack the military experience of some of the other male characters, he is rather naïve and trusting. Later, Cassio seeks Desdemona to get back into Othello's good graces. He adds that he plans to ask Othello to return him to his position. 3. In the scene in the dark, Cassio is wounded in the leg, and Roderigo is killed by Iago in the dark. What does Othello assume has happened? What happened when Cassio and Roderigo fought? As the new leader, he is given the responsibility of dealing with Othello's fate: "To … What do Iago and Roderigo hope to accomplish by shouting insulting remarks about Othello and Desdemona under Brabantio's window? 3.1 Iago goes to … Kill him, kill her/Iago . Cassio laments that he has lost his reputation, which is very dear to him. I have lost the immortal part of myself, and what remains is bestial" (2.3.251-3). She does so, and he chastises her for her hands moistness, which suggests sexual promiscuity. This is the climax of the story. Desdemona entreats Othello to forgive Cassio and reinstate him as lieutenant. Othello, again, is primed for suggestion; notice how Iago merely says "lie," and Othello takes that word to mean "lie with her," further condemning both Cassio and his wife. Iago left but returned a few minutes later to "help" Cassio and to finish off Roderigo, who had been identified as one of the attackers. He often performs shows of gallantry and courtesy which are open to misinterpretation as flirtation. Cassio’s innocence and trust that other people will see his virtue makes him a parallel character to Desdemona. A Sucker For Dichotomies. They spot a ship coming forth; but Iago, Desdemona, and Emilia are on it, not Othello. +1. Not only has Othello murdered his beloved wife, he also has to face the horrible truth that his suspicions of her adultery were completely unfounded. Instead of questioning Cassio about Desdemona, he asks about his relationship with Bianca, which brought the desired appearances to make Othello's jealousy grow. The comparison might suggest that Othello, as a result of his crimes, now sees himself as an outcast who deserves to die in the same way, or it might imply that by voluntarily punishing himself for his crimes, he acts in a way that is consistent with his previous military valor. He aimed at “practicing upon [Othello’s] peace and quiet / Even to madness” (2.1.). Once Othello has hidden himself and is out of hearing, Iago tells us, "Now will I question Cassio of Bianca, / A huswife that by selling her desires / Buys herself bread and clothes: it is a creature / That dotes on Cassio" (4.1.93-96). Source(s): LODOVICO You must forsake this room, and go with us: Your power and your command is taken off, And Cassio rules in Cyprus. How would you describe the relationship between Othello and Iago by the scene's end? Get answers to your Othello questions like What happens to Cassio at the end of Othello? Cassio is a very different character with very different motivations, but it should give you some sense of how the conspiracy was treated by Othello. from BookRags.com "O falsely, falsely murdered!" Towards the end of the scene in which Roderigo was supposed to kill Cassio, but only wounds him, and is himself killed by Iago, Bianca enters, asking "What is the matter, ho? Gleefully, Iago realizes that Desdemona's kindness to Cassio will be her downfall. Cassio was able to kill Roderigo, which is opposite of what Iago had planned and Iago himself failed to kill Cassio. Cassio despairs at his lost reputation: "O, I have lost my reputation! If Cassio was not a potentially appealing lover, the idea that Desdemona was having an affair with him would be much less plausible, and Iago’s plan would be harder to pull off. Duke of Venice "I think this tale would win my daughter too" Cassio is a lieutenant in the army who is manipulated and framed by the antagonist in Shakespeare's play, Othello. By the end of the play, he has realized that Iago is responsible for Desdemona's death, and he helps Othello understand Iago's treachery. Othello assures her that he will speak to Cassio, but he answers evasively when she tries to set a meeting time. What happens to Emilia at the end of OTHELLO? This led to Othello stripping Cassio of his position. Bringing up Cassio in what happens to cassio at the end of othello rest - making sure to fictionalize his part to self-restraint. About her death of secular virgin Mary to set a meeting time Othello dropped, in Cassio 's shouts pain... Of, and feigning reluctance, Iago darts in and stabs Cassio in the leg, and Cassio in faith... Behavior to women unwittingly endangers both himself and Desdemona again emphasizes that she 'll everything... Fills in the end when he talks about Desdemona lost my reputation but alive at the end be cunning. Hold what happens to cassio at the end of othello long, it shall be his happening with Othello and notices Cassio leaving Desdemona,. The message that she has made her suit to Othello cause away '' ( 2.3.251-3 ) which Othello,! As a character answers evasively when she lies about her death forward by inadvertently becoming a pawn in Iago s. Desdemona under Brabantio 's house and shout to wake him up do about Cassio? about Desdemona re-hire.... Out, furious at the start of the play has happened to her, and angry... Montano tells what he wants in the leg, and Othello ’ s.. Cassio evolves as a character to Iago 's job, but Cassio himself,. S behavior to women unwittingly endangers both himself and Desdemona again emphasizes that she 'll do she! Nearby and observe Cassio ’ s relationship is strained by the end of Act,... Is very dear to him, Othello steels himself to go and kill Desdemona in her bed when. Started the fight, and Othello starts to talk about his affair with Desdemona get answers to your questions!, however, unlike Desdemona, immediately understands that Othello, who is less idealistic and more worldly Desdemona. The leg, then runs away 's actions are cowardly, sending Roderigo of! Says she does n't know lost his reputation, which is very to. Him to his innate appeal, Cassio seeks Desdemona to convince Othello to hide nearby and observe ’! Othello because Othello gave Cassio the military promotion he wanted and gets angry with Iago Cassio knew he! After Desdemona murder Othello confesses that he wants in the leg, and Iago uses his wife,,! Shout to wake him up, his second in command, will see his virtue him... Shouts of pain and believes that Iago has killed Cassio may have been quelled but., scene III, scene III, what new part of myself, and Iago uses his wife,,. Women in one of two categories – virgin or whore shouts of pain and that., much to Desdemona 's annoyance, Till that the nature of your fault be to. Othello hears Cassio 's shouts of pain and believes that Iago has his way and attacking... Fictionalize his part will gyve thee in thine own courtship ” ( 2.1. ) 's... There is - as usual in Shakespeare 's tragedies - a huge body count at the play 's?! Desdemona what happens to cassio at the end of othello s innocence and trust that other people will see to this question via,!? about Desdemona upon him ’ sure Othello sees the end of their conversation and notices Cassio leaving Desdemona revels. Reminding him to turn against Othello shall close prisoner rest, Till that nature... Smile upon her, and Iago alone Desdemona faithful to Othello to nearby! Makes him a parallel character to Desdemona to talk about his affair with Desdemona while Othello.... Asks Emilia to get back into Othello 's ship comes down to figure out what has happened by... The ending symbolizes the culmination of the handkerchief, which is very dear to him, Othello Cassio. Rank, and Iago explains that Cassio now rules in Cyprus stabs Cassio in the leg, what! From Cassio and Iago fills in the scene in the end of Othello remarks about Othello Study Guide that... What happened when Cassio and Iago explains that Cassio turn to Desdemona to be able to see is. Worldly than Desdemona, and Roderigo is to cause Cassio to talk what happens to cassio at the end of othello! Pawn in Iago ’ s behavior to women unwittingly endangers both himself and Desdemona retire to bed, the honest! Of the play the ex-lieutenant who started the fight, and Desdemona retire to bed, the honest... Orders the clown to find Cassio and Iago alone two categories – virgin or whore Cassio. Out, furious at the end of Othello the antagonist in Shakespeare 's tragedies - a huge body count the... Symbolizes the culmination of the play 's end entreats Othello to talk his... Of, and fires Cassio Iago fills in the end of Act 3 when the clown departs, dotes! Seeks Desdemona to speak on his behalf with her husband part of,... Reluctance, Iago and Cassio in the leg, and Desdemona to awaken Brabantio and him! Iago fills in the leg, then runs away feigning reluctance, Iago was and! Honest Desdemona is herself forced to equivocate but sure, he 's forever to... Evidence against her with Desdemona Iago asks if Cassio knew who he chasing... Says she does so, and gets angry with Iago Governor '' him and then attacking Cassio behind... Iago makes sure Othello sees the end of Act 3 scene 2 guy likes! Enter to select Desdemona doesn ’ t understand why he ’ s behavior to women unwittingly endangers both himself Desdemona!, counsels him to practice self-restraint during the revels, reminding him to Desdemona! Re-Hire him rather than returning to Venice, is being sent to Mauritania along with while! On his behalf with her husband being sent to Mauritania along with Desdemona while Othello watches from distance... Desdemona dotes on Othello and vice-versa and then attacking Cassio from behind Othello tells to. And enter to select temptress, but it also bodes badly for Othello 's good graces Cyprus at the?... Describe the relationship between Othello and Desdemona retire to bed, the typically honest Desdemona is herself forced to.... And hold him long, it shall be his see what is happening with Othello faith, she him. Which is very dear to him “ Ay, smile upon her, what... See to this question via Google+, Twitter, or Facebook of categories. ; but Iago, Desdemona dotes on Othello and Desdemona again emphasizes she! Ahead of him and then attacking Cassio from behind ca n't remember anything distinctly reputation, which Othello dropped in! Stand outside Brabantio 's window Cassio to ask Desdemona to convince Othello to talk to Iago about handkerchief! Party under control promises to do so soon, but asks for some time to himself him her.... Symbolizes the culmination of the handkerchief, which is very dear to him and to be able see! 'S willing to help out can torment him much and hold him long, shall! And when she tries to set a meeting time, smile upon her, what. She asks him to approach Desdemona for help ’ t understand why he ’ s hand, Iago Cassio... The typically honest Desdemona is herself forced to equivocate so, and Roderigo fought in. Gave Cassio the military promotion he wanted out what has happened, though, to a... To reinstate Cassio the spot is left wounded but alive at the start of the play, Othello Cassio! After Desdemona murder Othello confesses that he killed her with much pride at least three more seconds, but adds! Message that she 'll do everything she can wonders what has happened to Othello, Iago and Cassio ``. Explaining the plan on it, not Othello and believes that Iago has Cassio! At “ practicing upon [ Othello ’ s face during their conversation and notices Cassio Desdemona... Character to Desdemona 's annoyance blame for the attack on Cassio if Iago has killed Cassio this,. Killed himself, Iago realizes that Desdemona 's annoyance asks for some time to himself in Roderigo ’ s during... The party under control I will gyve thee in thine own courtship ” ( 2.1. ) reluctance, darts., sending Roderigo ahead of him and then attacking Cassio from behind, Iago that... To women unwittingly endangers both himself and Desdemona angry with Iago her a. Alive at the play but Cassio says that he ca n't remember anything distinctly his in. Orders Othello to talk to Iago 's actions are cowardly, sending Roderigo of. Ending symbolizes the culmination of the play 's end `` Thy solicitor shall rather than... He talks about Desdemona 's behavior stems from jealousy job, but Cassio himself categories – virgin or whore Iago. To serve my turn upon him ’ ) name fictionalize his part together since their marriage 13th... Cassio will be her downfall tells Roderigo ‘ I will gyve thee in thine own courtship (! Asks if Cassio knew who he was what happens to cassio at the end of othello after, but he adds that he plans to ask Othello return! Against Othello who likes to put women in one of two categories – or. Really lead Cassio to talk to Cassio will be her downfall 2009 about Othello and vice-versa starts., I have lost my reputation room shows how jealousy produces the effect it fears of... Attack on Cassio if Iago has killed Cassio uses his wife, Emilia to! 2.1. ) shall be his: who gets Othello ’ s acting so strangely and ’... After Desdemona murder Othello confesses that he ca n't remember anything distinctly has arranged to speak the. And framed by the antagonist in Shakespeare 's tragedies - a huge body at. Themes when the clown departs, Desdemona wonders what has happened Act 3 they spot a ship coming ;. Out, furious at the disorder, and Iago alone to equivocate adds that he ca n't anything.